* Cryo turns down the lights
<leot> Welcome to The NetBSD Foundation Annual General Meeting 2024!
<leot> .
<leot> I will be the voice bot^W^Wmoderator for this year.
<leot> .
<leot> In the agenda we will have reports from:
<leot>  - board (billc)
<leot>  - secteam (billc)
<leot>  - releng (leot)
<leot>  - finance-exec (riastradh)
<leot>  - admins (spz)
<leot>  - membership-exec (wiz)
<leot>  - pkgsrc-pmc (wiz)
<leot>  - pkgsrc-security (leot)
<leot>  - gnats (dh)
<leot> .
<leot> If there are any last-minute additions please /msg me!
<leot> .
<leot> Q&A will be at the end.
<leot> .
<leot> When Q&A begins please /msg me "I have question for <team>"
<leot> or "I have question for <nick>" and I will give you voice
<leot> when it is your turn.
<leot> .
<leot> We can start with the board presentation!
<leot> Cryo, please go ahead
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> - submitted by billc for board:
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Hello, and welcome to the 22nd Annual General Meeting of The
<Cryo>  NetBSD Foundation.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  First off, I'd like to thank <leot> for volunteering to
<Cryo>  handle moderating and admins for doing the behind the scenes
<Cryo>  magic to make this event (and all our communication) possible.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> We finally release NetBSD-10 after years of development with innovative new features, improvements, and more
<Cryo>  bug fixes. Your commits are very much appreciated, as is your
<Cryo>  continued support of the foundation.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Now on to the report from the Board of Directors:
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  The NetBSD Foundation Board of Directors presents a consolidated
<Cryo>  list of the relevant and major actions that occurred since last
<Cryo>  AGM.  Quite a few discussions, actions, and follow-ups crossed
<Cryo>  multiple meetings. Very few meetings resulted in not reaching
<Cryo>  quorum. Check our weekly meeting minutes in:
<Cryo>  localsrc/tnf/board/minutes for the latest on our progress.
<Cryo>  During this period, new director(s) were elected by the members
<Cryo>  and officers were renewed or installed.
<Cryo> ?
<Cryo>  We continued with our Bronze level sponsorship support of
<Cryo>  BSDcan, AsiaBSDcon, and EuroBSDcon to improve our representation
<Cryo>  at conferences and developer summits.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  We participated in the Google Summer of Code for 2023 and
<Cryo>  attended the virtual Google Summer of Code Mentor Summit. We
<Cryo>  are currently participating in GSoC this year with 5 students!
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  o - Test root device and root file system selection
<Cryo>  o - ALTQ refactoring and NPF integration
<Cryo>  o - puffs(3) bindings for Lua + SquashFS in Lua
<Cryo>  o - Emulating Missing Linux Syscalls: Tackling ?The L2N Problem?
<Cryo>  o - Making Network Drivers MPSAFE in NetBSD 
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Like last year, we have provided core with a pre-approved,
<Cryo>  reasonable budget, to spend as they see most fit without an
<Cryo>  additional confirmation step from us.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  We continued to improve our interaction and relationships with
<Cryo>  vendors, as well as participating in industry PSIRT/CSIRT
<Cryo>  with commercial vendors and other open-source projects.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  The funded contracts continued for:
<Cryo>  o - improvements in release engineering
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  We are 75% through a fundraising campaign. Please consider
<Cryo>  donating, as we are a US IRS 501(c)3 charitable organization.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> [let us pause for a moment of silence]
<Cryo>  In memoriam: We were notified that Wayne Knowles (wdk@) had 
<Cryo>  passed beyond the rim at the end of 2022. We are eternally
<Cryo>  grateful for his contributions to the NetBSD/mipsco port, and are
<Cryo>  dedicating NetBSD-9.4 to his memory. We are honored to have had
<Cryo>  his support and friendship.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  It has been an honor and pleasure to continue working with
<Cryo>  abs, leot, khorben, mlelstv, riastradh, and wiz to accomplish all
<Cryo>  that we have in this year.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> .eof
<Cryo> I will go ahead and do the social media update:
<Cryo> - submitted for socialmedia by billc:
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  A non-scientific representation of Social Media Presence:
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  X, formerly Twitter: (very active)
<Cryo>  @netbsd still has 10,000 followers
<Cryo>  @pkgsrc has 694 followers down from 704
<Cryo>  NOTE: Due to changes in X/Twitter management, people have left.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  We have an account on the distributed social network
<Cryo>  ActivityPub ('the fediverse' or better known as Mastodon), where we
<Cryo>  have a small but dedicated fan base:
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  @netbsd@mastodon.sdf.org has 1800 followers up from 1077 (very active)
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Facebook: 2,400 3,200 down from 3,200 members (sort of active)
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  On IRC our numbers are stable. To help improve connectivity options,
<Cryo>  we have a Matrix bridge to our IRC channel.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  irc.libera.chat users: (very very active)
<Cryo>  #NetBSD: 284 up from 276 
<Cryo>  #NetBSD-code: 53 down from 59
<Cryo>  #pkgsrc: 109 up from 107
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> .eof
<leot> Thanks Cryo!
<leot> Next it's the secteam presentation... please go ahead Cryo!
<Cryo> and I'm back!
<Cryo> (presenting for agc)
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> - submitted by billc for secteam:
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  This is a brief report for security-team.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Since last AGM, there have been 8 NetBSD Security Advisories:
<Cryo>  -------------------------------------------------------------
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2024-001 Inadequate validation of user-supplied hostname
<Cryo>    in utmp_update(8)
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2023-007 multiple vulnerabilities in ftpd(8)
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2023-006 KDC-spoofing in pam_krb5
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2023-005 su(1) bypass via pam_ksu(8)
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2023-004 procfs environ exposure
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2023-003 Structure padding memory disclosures
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2023-002 Various compatibility syscall memory access issues
<Cryo>  NetBSD-SA2023-001 Multiple buffer overflows in USB drivers
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  There have been numerous bug fixes applied to the tree, pulled up to the
<Cryo>  NetBSD-10 branch, and in the NetBSD-9 and NetBSD-10 releases.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  NetBSD continues to be represented in a product security incident
<Cryo>  response working group with other operating system vendors, as well
<Cryo>  as a direct contact team with other BSD projects.  This framework
<Cryo>  allows us to better work with vendors requiring an embargoed and/or
<Cryo>  coordinated release with other operating systems. We can begin
<Cryo>  working on issues that affect NetBSD much faster, instead of only
<Cryo>  notified after an embargo is lifted. We are expanding the number
<Cryo>  of vendors as time goes on, as well as participating in FIRST.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  This is teaching us quite a bit of where we needed to improve our
<Cryo>  process, which is currently on-going.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Submitted respectfully on behalf of the security-officer(s),
<Cryo>  the security-team, and the sirt team.
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> .eof
<leot> Thanks again Cryo!
<leot> We have not the releng@ presentation, prepared by <martin>. He's AFK so I will present it.
<leot> -
<leot> We are:
<leot> abs agc bouyer he jdc martin msaitoh phil reed riz
<leot> sborrill snj
<leot>  
<leot> Since the last meeting, we have:
<leot> o - Released NetBSD 10.0, 9.4 and 8.3
<leot> o - announced end-of-support for netbsd-8
<leot> o - Processed hundreds of pullup requests.
<leot> o - Continued preparations to make the build cluster
<leot> independent from cvs
<leot>  
<leot> The biggest hurdle was the long and stony way to
<leot> finaly get 10.0 out of the door. Now we are heading
<leot> for 10.1. Since nothing urgent poped up so far
<leot> (that is: no disaster have been discovered in the
<leot> 10.0 release) we can give it a few month, maybe
<leot> late september.
<leot>  
<leot> The massive ammount of pullups that got into the netbsd-10
<leot> branch was only possible because developers took the time
<leot> to test their changes on the branch and submit a
<leot> pullup request. We have been pretty good with this,
<leot> and pulled up lots of security and usability improvements,
<leot> as well as bug fixes to the various active branches.
<leot> This is good for our users, thank you to everyone who
<leot> cared and made it possible.
<leot>  
<leot> We are now looking forward to a netbsd-11 branch (maybe
<leot> late this year) and hope that this time things will go
<leot> a lot faster and more smoothly. This is currently planned
<leot> to include the new wifi work, but we are not going to
<leot> delay the branch if that will not be ready. Watch me poking
<leot> my onw nose - the wifi work has been massively delayed
<leot> due to heavy releng workload, but that should be over now.
<leot>  
<leot> Thanks to everyone who tested the branch and filled tickets,
<leot> and keep both the tickets and the pullup requests coming!
<leot> -
<leot> EOF
<leot> Thanks Martin!
<leot> It is now time for finance-exec@ presentation. Riastradh, please go ahead!
<Riastradh> Finance-exec maintains The NetBSD Foundation's financial records and
<Riastradh> assets at the board's direction.  We balance the books, hoard the cash
<Riastradh> (and non-cash financial instruments), and send thank-you letters to
<Riastradh> donors so they can get tax deductions (in the US).
<Riastradh> .
<Riastradh> We are:
<Riastradh> - christos (Christos Zoulas)
<Riastradh> - reed (Jeremy C Reed)
<Riastradh> - riastradh (Taylor R Campbell)
<Riastradh> .
<Riastradh> The NetBSD Foundation's public 2023 financial report is at:
<Riastradh> https://www.NetBSD.org/foundation/reports/financial/2023.html
<Riastradh> We produce this from an internal ledger maintained with ledger(1)
<Riastradh> <https://www.ledger-cli.org/>.
<Riastradh> .
<Riastradh> Highlights:
<Riastradh> - We have net assets of a little over 270k USD.
<Riastradh> - We took in about 61k USD -- well over our usual annual target!
<Riastradh> - We also spent 45k USD, primarily on release engineering, wifi update,
<Riastradh>   and new server hardware for package builds.
<Riastradh> - We expect to increase spending this year to replace our aging NetBSD
<Riastradh>   autobuild cluster too and finish the wifi update.
<Riastradh> .
<Riastradh> We have been working on better automating the donation thank-you
<Riastradh> process, which is currently only semiautomated -- requires clicking a
<Riastradh> dozen different buttons to process an RT ticket, something Christos
<Riastradh> usually does in a batch once a month, in case you were wondering why it
<Riastradh> takes so long to get a donation acknowledgment (sorry!).  We had a GSoC
<Riastradh> student to work on this but the project stalled after GSoC.
<Riastradh> .
<Riastradh> Happy to answer any questions about what finance-exec does, or swap
<Riastradh> notes on using ledger(1)!
<Riastradh> Thanks,
<Riastradh> -Riastradh, on behalf of finance-exec
<leot> Thank you Riastradh!
<leot> It is now time for the admins@ presentation! spz, please go ahead!
<spz> good localtime() all
<spz> ,
<spz> admins is the following people:
<spz> christos, dogcow, kim, mspo, phil, riastradh, riz, seb, soda, spz, tls
<spz> ,
<spz> Statistics:
<spz> - admins runs the following TNF systems:
<spz> @ TastyLime
<spz> + 8 hardware systems and 6 Xen guests
<spz> = 1 earmv7hf, the rest amd64
<spz> @ Columbia University
<spz> + 10 hardware systems
<spz> = all amd64
<spz> @ Washington University
<spz> + 7 hardware systems
<spz> = 1 earmv7hf, 1 aarch64 and the rest amd64
<spz> @ Regensburg (commercial housing)
<spz> + 2 hardware systems, one of them with 2 Xen guests,
<spz> = all amd64
<spz> ,
<spz> - CDN services donated by Fastly
<spz> - Housing donated by TastyLime, WWU, Columbia and spz
<spz> ,
<spz> NetBSD versions in use:
<spz> 1   pre-8.1 (earmv7hf, a console server)
<spz> 1   8.1_STABLE (earmv7hf, a console server)
<spz> 1   9.0_STABLE
<spz> 4   9.1_STABLE
<spz> 10  9.2_STABLE
<spz> 4   9.3_STABLE
<spz> 1   9.4
<spz> 1   9.99.*
<spz> 1   10.0_BETA
<spz> 2   10.0_RC1
<spz> 1   10.0_STABLE
<spz> ,
<spz> Changes:
<spz> We retired 4 hardware systems and gained 2 new ones, which are @WWU:
<spz> + babylon4 which is running anita tests
<spz> + shadow which is doing package builds for x86_64 and i386. With shadow,
<spz> the "time to packages" after a new pkgsrc branch has been cut from
<spz> 2-3 weeks to 2-3 days.
<spz> ,
<spz> Riastradh spent quite some time on the mail system to make it do DKIM etc
<spz> so we can still send mail to Google mail accounts.
<spz> ,
<spz> Notable plans:
<spz> We will have to leave Columbia and will use the occasion to update the
<spz> build environment so that the new location receives less RU.
<spz> ,
<spz> I will be updating servers the next two weeks since I have some time off,
<spz> be forewarned.
<spz> ,
<spz> Thanks to riz, tls and phil for their resources, time
<spz> and blood sacrifices, too. :}
<spz> ,
<spz> Back to moderator.
<leot> Thank you spz!
<leot> It's now time for membership-exec presentation! wiz00, please go ahead!
<wiz00> (This presentation was prepared by martin@ who can't be here today.)
<wiz00>         -
<wiz00> The current members of membership-exec are:
<wiz00>     - Christos Zoulas <christos>
<wiz00>     - Martin Husemann <martin>
<wiz00>     - Lex Wennmacher <wennmach>
<wiz00>     - Thomas Klausner <wiz>, and
<wiz00>     - Ken Hornstein <kenh> who is on sabbatical.
<wiz00>         -
<wiz00> Membership-exec is responsible for all aspects of
<wiz00> "membership", but in practice the main task is to handle
<wiz00> membership applications. The number of active developers
<wiz00> (as of 2024-05-16) is 146. Note that this number is a
<wiz00> bit outdated, as the commit counting required for the
<wiz00> board election has not yet happened for this year.
<wiz00>         -
<wiz00> Since the last AGM we gained 5 new developers, which
<wiz00> is way too few. We need to invite more people,
<wiz00> please help active users and encourage them to apply.
<wiz00>         -
<wiz00> The difference between developers and active developers
<wiz00> is explained in the bylaws - an active developer has
<wiz00> actually committed something in the last year, or contributed
<wiz00> in an active way, like admins.
<wiz00>         -
<wiz00> We'd like to emphasize that we appreciate all your replies
<wiz00> to our membership RFC e-mails, although we do not usually
<wiz00> acknowledge them. Please keep on providing feedback to
<wiz00> the RFC mails.
<wiz00> that's it from membership-exec.
<leot> Thank you wiz00!
<leot> It's now the time for the pkgsrc-pmc@ presentation... Please go ahead wiz00!
<wiz00> The pkgsrc team kept thousands of packages in pkgsrc up to date and in
<wiz00> good working order, and delivered four -- the 79th through 82nd --
<wiz00> stable branches. Great work!
<wiz00>           -
<wiz00> The pkgsrc team has welcomed one new developer, ktnb.
<wiz00>           -
<wiz00> Bigger planned changes for the near future:
<wiz00> - phase-out of Python version 2
<wiz00> - switching the pkgsrc repository to git
<wiz00> - deprecating Python 3.8 support since many upstreams started doing
<wiz00>   that
<wiz00>           -
<wiz00> Topics that could do with help
<wiz00> - keeping rust working on NetBSD platforms outside of amd64
<wiz00> - maintaining the pkg-vulnerability database in pkgsrc/doc
<wiz00>   pkgsrc-security needs more people!
<wiz00>           -
<wiz00> Thank you for your help!
<wiz00> -- wiz, for pkgsrc-pmc
<leot> Thanks again wiz00!
<leot> It is now time for pkgsrc-security presentation. This presentation was prepared by Thomas Merkel <tm> but he's AFK and I will present it.
<leot> -
<leot> The mission of the pkgsrc Security Team is to ensure that the ever-growing
<leot> ecosystem of third party software is either safe to use or at least be sure
<leot> people are aware of the known vulnerabilities.
<leot>         -
<leot> Our members monitor publicly available vulnerability feeds, mainly CVE.
<leot>         -
<leot> We aggregate received advisories believed to impact pkgsrc into the pkgsrc
<leot> vulnerability list. When time allows we try to notify individual package
<leot> MAINTAINERs and locate, commit patches to fix the vulnerabilities.
<leot>         -
<leot> Since 2021 our ticket handling crew is currently only 2 people, unfortunately
<leot> pretty understaffed. We are looking and welcome people volunteering to join
<leot> us!
<leot>         -
<leot> Currently handling tickets are:
<leot>  - Leonardo Taccari <leot>
<leot>  - Thomas Merkel <tm>
<leot>         -
<leot> The other current members of the team are:
<leot>  - Thomas Klausner <wiz>
<leot>  - Tobias Nygren <tnn>
<leot>  - Tim Zingelman <tez>
<leot>         -
<leot> The year in numbers:
<leot> In 2023, the vulnerability list had 717 lines added to it (661 less than last
<leot> year) for a total of 30401 known vulnerabilities.
<leot> In 2022, the ticket queue received 30401 new advisories (3971 more than last
<leot> year). Of these 30401 new advisories:
<leot>  new:       1027 ( 3.4%) (not able to handle in 2023)
<leot>  stalled:      0 ( 0.0%)
<leot>  resolved:   717 ( 2.3%) (affecting pkgsrc packages)
<leot>  rejected: 28653 (94.3%) (no impact or duplicates)
<leot>         -
<leot> The current count of vulnerable packages in pkgsrc-current is 707 (33 less
<leot> than last year), in pkgsrc-stable is 729 (21 less than last year).
<leot> See the periodic email to packages@NetBSD.org for the list.
<leot> But we've 2834 vulnerabilities to review!
<leot> We can always use help locating and committing security patches, in particular
<leot> for the many of these that are maintained by pkgsrc-users.
<leot>         -
<leot> On November 2023 NVD deprecated the RSS feed that we used for getting
<leot> CVE vulnerabilities entries. <tm> and <wiz> have written a script to switch
<leot> to the NIST National Vulnerability Database API. If you are more
<leot> curious it is available under
<leot>   localsrc/security/pkgsrc-security/programs/cve2email.py.
<leot> Thanks <tm> and <wiz>!
<leot>         -
<leot> We encourage all developers to help us keep the vulnerability list up-to-date.
<leot> If you become aware of a security issue or perform a security update in pkgsrc
<leot> please edit the list. You don't need any special privilege for this.
<leot> You'll find the list in pkgsrc CVS repository:
<leot>  pkgsrc/doc/pkg-vulnerabilities
<leot>         -
<leot> Please join the pkgsrc Security ticket handling crew, we're pretty understaffed
<leot> at the moment! Feel free to get in touch with us for additional details or an
<leot> introduction.
<leot>         -
<leot> EOF
<leot> Next we have... gnats presentation! dholland, please go ahead!
<dholland> Here's the bug database report since the last AGM (12 months):
<dholland>  
<dholland> GNATS statistics for 2023 (as of May 18 2024)
<dholland>  
<dholland> New PRs this year: 858, of which 593 are still open.
<dholland> Closed PRs this year: 551. Net change: +307.
<dholland> Total PRs touched this year: 1057.
<dholland> Oldest PR touched this year: 3019.
<dholland> Oldest open PR: 1677; PR ignored for the longest: 4691.
<dholland>  
<dholland> Total number open: 6348
<dholland>  
<dholland> Last year after resisting for some time we went past 6000 open;
<dholland> having crossed that psychological barrier, this year the backlog
<dholland> has pretty much just steadily increased.
<dholland>  
<dholland> There's always more volume with a release in the works. This
<dholland> year's new PR count is up by almost 50% over last year, and the
<dholland> number closed is almost as large as last year's total influx.
<dholland> More traffic is not exactly a good thing, but it's not really
<dholland> bad either, because it seems to reflect community engagement.
<dholland>  
<dholland> This is the weekly plot:
<dholland>  
<dholland>                                                        *  6380
<dholland>                                                  ********
<dholland>                                               ***********                                              ***********
<dholland>                                           ***************
<dholland>                                   ***********************
<dholland>               *          ********************************
<dholland>    ****************************************************** 6020
<dholland>  
<dholland> (sorry, seem to have messed that up slightly, ignore the insert)
<dholland>  
<dholland> Note that the variation shown in the graph is only around 5% of
<dholland> the total. If it used zero as the origin the limits of ASCIIthe total. If it used zero as the origin the limits of ASCII
<dholland> plots would leave the line entirely flat.
<dholland>  
<dholland> Handling the backlog remains difficult. This is mostly a tooling
<dholland> problem; alas, resources and energy to deal with it are scarce.
<dholland>  
<dholland> If anyone was wondering, the oldest open PR (PR 1677) is about a
<dholland> panic in unionfs. This is unfortunately still current. The most
<dholland> untouched PR (PR 4691) is about ECC memory handling on sun3;
<dholland> it's new to this spot because of activity in the old one (PR
<dholland> 3019) this year.
<dholland>  
<dholland> Anyhow, here are the people who've been fixing the most bugs, as
<dholland> counted by commit messages found in PRs closed during the year.
<dholland>  
<dholland>   20  martin@netbsd.org
<dholland>   22  rin@netbsd.org
<dholland>   30  wiz@netbsd.org
<dholland>   32  christos@netbsd.org
<dholland>  133  riastradh@netbsd.org
<dholland>  
<dholland> This list always has a very long tail; this year there were 63
<dholland> people who fixed or helped fix at least one bug report. This is
<dholland> down slightly from last year, but only by a little. Thanks to
<dholland> one and all.
<dholland>  
<dholland> And here are those who've been processing pullups, according to
<dholland> the same analysis:
<dholland>  
<dholland>    1  msaitoh@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>    1  riz@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>    1  sborrill@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>    1  snj@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>    2  spz@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>    8  bsiegert@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>    9  bouyer@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>  248  martin@netbsd.org (releng)
<dholland>  
<dholland> This is skewed far more toward Martin even than last year. Many,
<dholland> many, many thanks, Martin.
<dholland>  
<dholland> <eot>
<leot> Thanks dholland!
<leot> We can start the Q&A time. If you have any questions please `/msg leot <question>` and I will voice you.
<leot> No questions?
<leot> OK! Let's go ahead... Cryo, the floor is your!
<leot> Whoops, sorry!
<leot> One question!
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Thanks to all the places that host our server machines and thanks to
<Cryo>  all kind heroes who do hands-on work too on them!
<PGoyette> for core(?) what are plans for maintaining "currency" of video drivers?  riastradh@ did a huge amount of work in 10.0 but we are already falling far behind current hardware.  Perhaps a funded position would help?
<Riastradh> We'll do a drm update, I was mostly waiting for netbsd-10.
<PGoyette> thanks.  are you targetting 11.0?
<Riastradh> hope so
<PGoyette> great!
<leot> Thanks PGoyette and Riastradh! We have another question in the queue.
<andvar> for releng: the pullups are handled by martin mainly. Is it expected and is there a need or way to reduce his load on this?
<leot> Anyone from releng and/or who can answer that? (if you do not have voice feel free to /msg me)
<Riastradh> andvar: martin is doing a lot of the releng work on a part-time consulting basis (part of the $17k we paid on consulting last year), so that's expected, but also it wouldn't hurt to have more releng hands.
<andvar> OK, thanks. In case hands are needed, this work may be possible for me from time to time.
<leot> Thanks andvar and Riastradh!
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Thanks to all the executive committees who do a lot of work behind the
<Cryo>  scenes to keep everything running smoothly!
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Thanks to everyone who is running our services, participating and
<Cryo>  helping in mailing lists, chat and other communities and filling PRs!
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Finally, thank you, for being part of this process today, fixing bugs,
<Cryo>  committing new features and making NetBSD and pkgsrc the best operating
<Cryo>  system and packaging system!
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  We couldn't do it without you, and please keep up the excellent work!
<Cryo> -
<Cryo> -
<Cryo>  Respectfully submitted on behalf of the Board of Directors
<Cryo> .eof
<Cryo> Now, let's crank it up to 11.
<Cryo>  o/ Thank you all for coming
<Cryo>  We appreciate you taking time to come to our AGM
<Cryo>  We look forward to the NetBSD-11 release, and seeing you at the next AGM
<Cryo> (optimistically)
* Cryo closes the curtains and gets the broom out for the popcorn on the floor... watch out for spilled drinks.
<Cryo>  EOF
<Cryo>  Copyright 2024, The NetBSD Foundation, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Objects may appear closer in mirrors.
* spz whaps Cryo with a small trout for the pun
<Cryo> who left these bricks laying around?
<Cryo> See y'all next year!